The ideal kitchen floor would be inexpensive, beautiful, indestructible, waterproof, easy to install, and eco-friendly.  Sounds perfect doesn’t it? Unfortunately, no single material has all these qualities, thus we must compromise.  The following are six popular kitchen floor materials, how they compare on those six qualities, arranged by price in ascending order:

  1. Vinyl ($)

Vinyl is a popular synthetic material that is soft under foot and comes with a modest price tag.  While vinyl can be used to replicate natural materials such as stone or wood, it’s unlikely to fool anyone upon a close inspection.  It’s very durable against chipping, scratches, and scuffing, although it’s vulnerable to being punctured.  Its typical lifespan is between 10 and 20 years.  One of vinyl’s main selling points is that it’s impervious to water, making it excellent for kitchens and bathrooms.  The installation process tends to be very easy and inexpensive, although it’s not the eco-friendliest option unless you are willing to pay extra.

  1. Laminate ($$)

Laminate is another inexpensive and soft synthetic flooring that replicates natural materials.  It’s durable against burns, dents, and scratches, making it an excellent material for high traffic areas and houses with pets.  The average lifespan is between 10 and 30 years.  Without slip-resistant wear layers it can be slippery when wet, while also lacking the tremendous water resistance that vinyl has.  It’s a do-it-yourself crowd favorite as the pieces snap together like puzzles, while also being eco-friendlier than vinyl.

  1. Ceramic ($$)

Ceramic is made from sand or clay and is the entry-point to natural flooring.  It’s aesthetically pleasing with an enormous variety of colors and styles.  However, it tends to be cold to the touch and hard underfoot without a padded underlayment.  Ceramic is resistant to scratches or cracks, but if it does, repairs can be difficult.  The average lifespan is approximately 50 years.  Even when glazed and treated, your tiles may not be totally water or slip-proof.  Installation is best left to professionals due to the skill required, the labor intensity, and the variety of required tools, grouts, mortars, and other materials.  It’s environmentally friendly and often recycled, making it a winner for the ecologically conscious.

  1. Cork ($$-$$$)

Cork flooring is beloved for its cushioning underfoot, which is fantastic in areas like the kitchen where you will be frequently standing.  Its patterning is stylish and distinct.  Quality cork can be as durable as hardwood with the right finish, however its susceptible to sharp punctures.  Large dogs can damage the surface with their nails and heavy furniture should be placed on coasters to mitigate any damage.  It has an average lifespan of 25 years and can be refinished just as hardwood can.  Cork is hypoallergenic, antimicrobial, and moisture resistant, hence its use in wine bottles.  Cork is much easier to install than traditional hardwood flooring, and is typically harvested in a sustainable eco-friendly way. 

  1. Hardwood ($$$)

Hardwood flooring is timelessly stylish.  Its widespread appeal and durability tend to improve a home’s resale value when compared to vinyl, laminate or ceramic.  While hardwood can be scratched or scuffed, many consider this to be part of its aesthetic.  The average lifespan of hardwood is between 40 and 80 years.  While it is water resistant, it is not waterproof, so spills should be tended to quickly.  The installation is expensive and labor intensive, but with the right supplier and source, it can be an eco-friendly option.

  1. Stone ($$$$)

Much like hardwood, stone has tremendous aesthetic appeal and can boost your home’s resale value.  Stone tends to require very little maintenance due to its longevity and durability.  The lifespan of stone averages between 75 and 100 years.  Its water resistance depends upon how porous the type of stone is and whether it’s sealed.  Stone tiles are among the priciest options, and come with a difficult and expensive installation.  It is also difficult and pricey to replace damaged tiles.  However, since it is a natural material that doesn’t require a lot of manufacturing, it is quite an eco-friendly flooring option.

When it comes to choosing your kitchen floor, it’s a matter of aligning the strengths and weaknesses of each material with your budget.  There is no singular perfect floor, but rather a variety of options to choose from.



Tags: , , , , , , , ,